Thursday, 30 June 2016

Brexit or Austry?

Brexit has been exercising the world for the last fortnight or so. Clearly a lot of older Brits have been thinking about it for much longer. Now Europe is showing the UK the door with almost unseemly haste (here's your hat, what's your hurry?), and the kingdom itself looks set to diminish to the boundaries of a far more ancient Britain. 

England's xenophobic tendencies run like tributary streams through its history of exploration, empire building and colonisation, and have from time to time made its people loathed around the world. Other present-day descendants of my ancestors, almost exclusively Celts of Cornish and Irish extraction, may well soon tell the English (with a range of appropriate hand gestures) exactly what they think of them, and ask to stay with Europe instead. 

In Australia, we struggle as much with the inheritance of this xenophobia as any other former colony. For the past twenty years, since the rise of Pauline Hanson, the suspect dimensions of our lineage have been most evident in official and unofficial attitudes towards Asians, Arabs, and asylum seekers. And, of course, the perennial targets, Australian Aborigines. Bossed around and intervened against left right and centre.

Currently we seem intent on being unconscionably cruel under the guise of kindness towards refugees, consigning indefinitely some of the most desperate of their number either to Nauru, an exposed block of guano in the middle of the Pacific; or to Manus Island in Papua New Guinea (PNG), a country that was itself Australia's only colony, blessed and cursed with abundant natural resources but a parlously weak state apparatus. 

The absurdity of this as a 'solution' to the regional refugee problem is evident in the approx $10M per person granted to Cambodia some years ago to take a few of the people refused entry to Australia, resulting in a majestically grand total of four resettlements, the majority of whom have already left; and in the handful of refugees who attempted to make a life in PNG as they were promised they could, an enterprise so dangerous that they asked, and were refused, permission to re-enter the Manus Island detention centre rather than face the violence and constant sense of unease they met in the wider community. 

Austry


Meanwhile, as the UK considers Brexit, the Australian state, supported by a largely misled and in fact quite narrow majority, refuses to expand the definition of what I'm proposing we should call Austry ('oz-tree'): open entry to Australia, welcome, support, and genuine asylum for refugees and voluntary migrants both skilled and unskilled. Not open slather - immigration always has to be moderated by the limits of our resources - but enough of this pretending we have nothing to offer the desperate, that they have nothing to offer us, that, in the broadest of our lingo, they should all fuck off because we're full.

Australia as a nation is founded on two principles: first on the dignity and capacity for accommodation of the newcomer displayed by its Indigenous populations, cultural mores that have been sorely abused since the entry of England's unwanted prison population and their guards in 1788; and second, on the various phases of cautious, at times hostile but in the end open entry to migrants and refugees in the 200-odd years since.

This issue, after years of prevarication and native loyalty to Labor, is going to be the primary determinant of the way I vote in the Australian Federal election tomorrow.

Beyond the TINA of Brexit


Margaret Thatcher was apparently in the habit of brooking opposition by intoning There Is No Alternative when presented with a dissenting view. Since then, TINA has been an ongoing refrain from the conservative side of politics. My personal view is that that's rubbish. There is always an alternative, and the urge for reform has to be tempered by the consideration of a diversity of views. And so I'm using this forum to present a position of my own, diametrically opposed to Baroness Thatcher's.

Tempting as it might be, especially in a post-TINA world, I cannot deny my own Englishness. One of the first of my forebears to enter this country, Thomas Barnett, was a boy from Uxbridge. He came to Australia as a convict at 21 years of age, after he and a mate stole three sheets and a tablecloth from a neighbour's yard. He was tried in the Middlesex sessions of September 1831 and pronounced guilty, sentenced to seven years' transportation, and sent to Sydney Town on the convict ship Portsmouth a matter of months later. As an emancipee after fourteen years of indentured labour, he married an Irishwoman, Ellen Cochrane or Corkerry, who has her own sorry history (hopefully the subject of a later post), and moved to Greta in Victoria, thus becoming a bystander in the most iconic tale of defiance of authority in post-settlement Australian history, that of Ned Kelly.

My great-great-grandfather's son, my great-uncle, also called Thomas, is called out as a 'cur' in the Jerilderie letter. His sister-in-law, my great-grandmother Hannah Barnett nee Asquith nee Murtagh, regularly visited Ned's mother in Greta after she, Ellen Kelly, was released from prison in the aftermath of her son's notorious hanging. Such is life. The Irish are clannish, and they understand the aftermath of trauma only too well, especially at the hands of the English.

Despite it all, there is still much to love in the carnivalesque dance of my heritage, including the English parts. This little video, a meditation on family and friendship from the perspective of an Australian with English, Irish and Cornish roots, is an attempt to soothe the savage beasts without and within. What's evident in most of its images is the persistent whiteness of my background. But in glimpses of friends, and friends of friends, and the places they've taken me, there is the tiniest trace of the time-honoured Indigenous notion of country. 

At its best, country is shared and loved and cared for, and the needs of all inhabitants are accommodated. I would hope that the English of today, and their descendants, could learn from this beautiful and delicate tradition.

I will be forever grateful to have been granted the privilege of growing up in the heart of Wiradjuri country, simply by accident of birth. In our words, my childhood was spent 400 miles from Sydney in south-western New South Wales, on a farm 8 miles from the town of Griffith, not far from a little village called Tharbogang (pronounced 'Tar-bo-gan'), which means, variously, "meeting place by the water" and "old woman". Both these meanings have profound resonances for me, a descendant of pirates, convicts, scoundrels and assorted ratbags, all of whom have miraculously been allowed to thrive, raise families, grow old and die in the bosom of this ancient continent.

The Aboriginal Tent Embassy, Canberra.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aboriginal_Tent_Embassy 

The Gurindji Strike, or Wave Hill Walk-Off
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurindji_strike 

Australian Aboriginal domestic scene depicting traditional recreation, including one child kicking the "ball", with the object and caption being to "never let the ball hit the ground". (From William Blandowski's Australien in 142 Photographischen Abbildungen, 1857, (Haddon Library, Faculty of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge))
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woggabaliri